Right after lawsuit versus Portsmouth Abbey, police reopen investigation dozens of alums demand adjust

In a letter to the Board of Regents obtained by the Globe, Abbey alumni demanded that the school’s most important leadership — Headmaster Daniel McDonough, Assistant Headmaster John Perreira, and Board of Regents Chair Christopher Behnke — be put on leave for the period of the investigation.

“The university experienced the chance to arrive clear about every thing, and they did not,” reported Frank Pagliaro, a 2010 alumnus and former school member, in an job interview. “All this outrage genuinely led me to commence writing a letter. I’ve experienced input from a large amount of alums.”

The Abbey did not quickly react to requests for remark on the letter, which was signed by alumni who graduated in yrs spanning from the early 1970s to 2019.

The lawsuit was filed by an nameless previous student whom the Globe is identifying by the very first letter of her identify, E.

Filed in Rhode Island federal court, the lawsuit mentioned E. was sexually abused by a trainer, Michael Bowen Smith, beginning when she was a 15-12 months-previous sophomore. It also said that the Abbey not only unsuccessful to defend E. as a student, but also set her up to get poor authorized suggestions that benefited the faculty.

Smith has not responded to requests for comment on the allegations.

E., by her law firm Dave Ring, claimed the alumni reaction manufactured a difference.

“It has been unpleasant and isolating to relive and publicize my experiences at the Abbey, but the aid I’ve acquired from fellow alumni and some others has assisted me know that I am not on your own,” she explained in a statement.

Till the faculty satisfied their demands, the alumni and other individuals wrote, “we will be not able, in great conscience, to make donations, solicit donations, attend Faculty events, or persuade some others to take into consideration sending their have kids to the Faculty.”

“I’ve been devoted to the school for 55 several years. Don’t weasel with me. If the kids knew, the college understood,” mentioned an alumnus who began at the university in 1966 and signed on to the letter, but asked for anonymity due to the fact of his do the job.

The lawsuit alleged that the Abbey paid out for E. to be represented by a regulation business in New Mexico that never ever instructed her the statute of limitations to bring action towards her previous boarding faculty would shortly expire. University directors “wanted to keep the possible scandal contained, and commenced to do so by ‘steering’ Plaintiff to use the School’s outside the house consultant to ‘help’ her out of this predicament,” the lawsuit suggests.

Lawsuits were submitted towards the legislation business, Lewis Roca Rothgerber Christie, in New Mexico and towards Portsmouth Abbey and Smith in Rhode Island before this month.

Lewis Roca Rothgerber Christie strongly disputed the allegations, saying the prepared scope of the firm’s engagement was slender and couldn’t have provided suggestions about Rhode Island regulation, and that E.’s arrangement to have the college reimburse her for the expenses was manufactured in advance of the firm was contacted and with out its involvement.

In their letter, the alumni pressed the college to response a sequence of queries about E.’s scenario, which include no matter whether the Abbey granted the condition lawyer basic complete accessibility to data and witnesses less than its handle following E. claimed the abuse whether the Abbey presented tips for Smith when he sought employment elsewhere and no matter if any guardian was threatened with a child’s dismissal for making an attempt to discuss the allegations with the faculty.

The alumni also requested the university to make a committee built up of “alumni, Board customers, employees, and outside counsel” to conduct the investigation.


Zoe Greenberg can be arrived at at [email protected] Stick to her on Twitter @zoegberg.