Lawsuit: Judge Andrew Napolitano Assaulted Charles Corbishley

Warning: facts involved in this tale are graphic.

Previous judge and current Fox Information judicial analyst Andrew Napolitano was sued for sexual assault, battery and intentional infliction of psychological distress in Manhattan federal courtroom on Friday. Napolitano states the rates are totally false.

In accordance to the criticism acquired by Legislation&Crime, in 1988, Napolitano lured Charles Corbishley to his New Jersey household less than untrue pretenses and pressured him to complete oral sexual intercourse.

At the time, Napolitano was the judge presiding above Corbishley’s circumstance on costs of criminal arson. His law firm, Robert Hollis, was allegedly a self-described “friend” of Napolitano’s and correctly moved to have the situation introduced less than his purview. Hollis then purportedly organized for Corbishley to do yard operate at Napolitano’s Hackensack residence–presumably in trade for judicial leniency.

“Mr. Corbishley complied with his attorney’s request, and went to the home as he had been instructed,” the filing said. “Upon arrival at the residence, Mr. Corbishley rang the doorbell, and Defendant answered the door. Plaintiff then handed in excess of [a] Christmas card to Defendant ANDREW NAPOLITANO and told him that he was there to shovel snow.”

In accordance to the  lawsuit, on the other hand, there was no snow wherever.

“Defendant NAPOLITANO then instructed Plaintiff to shovel the driveway, starting up out in the front and then to work his way all-around the house,” the filing continued. “Plaintiff identified this request to be peculiar, because the driveway now experienced been shoveled, and there did not appear to be any major snow all over the house that essential shoveling. In simple fact, all Plaintiff could see was a layer of ice on the ground, but there was minimal, if any snow, close to the home.”

Corbishley, 20-decades-outdated at the time, then started using tobacco a cigarette and “pondered what to do next” simply because he did not have an understanding of why he was essentially there.

The lawsuit claimed that Napolitano “shortly” exited the property and approached Corbishley, summoning him to the aspect of the household by asking: “can you appear again listed here for a moment?” Corbishley claimed he complied with the ask for. And, at to start with, Napolitano allegedly just engaged him in little chat about his family and a pharmacy in city.

The filing described the alleged attack in graphic element [emphasis in original]:

Defendant NAPOLITANO then approached Plaintiff CHARLES CORBISHLEY, and stated “you know, you could be likely away for a long time.” As Defendant was talking to Plaintiff, he proceeded to location his hand on Plaintiff’s shoulder, and forced Plaintiff to his knees. As he pushed Plaintiff down toward the ground, Defendant explained to Plaintiff to “be a great boy.” At this issue, Defendant NAPOLITANO appeared to be masturbating through his clothing, relocating his hand back and forth around his penis. Thereafter, Defendant NAPOLITANO pulled his erect penis out. Plaintiff Charles Corbishley was then compelled to conduct fellatio on the Honorable Andrew Napolitano, the presiding Justice on his legal circumstance.

“At this second, Plaintiff was paralyzed with dread,” the lawsuit ongoing. “He required desperately to end Defendant NAPOLITANO’s sexual assault, but he was terrified about what Choose Napolitano would do to him if he resisted or fought again. Centered on the electrical power disparity amongst Judge Napolitano and Corbishley, it was unachievable for Plaintiff CHARLES CORBISHLEY to have ‘consented’ to any sexual functions with NAPOLITANO.”

The filing also graphically recounted the finish of the alleged incident and aftermath:

As Defendant started to ejaculate into Plaintiff’s mouth, Plaintiff took off crying and ran absent. Plaintiff was only 20 years outdated at the time of this sexual assault. Plaintiff then stopped by a close by diner and desperately tried out to clean himself and take away the semen from his garments, facial area and mouth.

About two times afterwards, for every the lawsuit, Corbishley’s law firm appeared to praise what had allegedly transpired involving his shopper and Napolitano.

“During this discussion, Mr. Hollis intimated that he understood specifically what experienced took place in between Decide Napolitano and Mr.  Corbishley,” the submitting alleged. “Specifically, Hollis instructed Mr. Corbishley one thing to the outcome that ‘we both of those have him now,’ and ‘don’t fear about nearly anything.’”

Corbishley was in the long run granted probation and neighborhood services.

A later slate of felony charges–in violation of his probation–were also far more or a lot less extinguished.

“The Courtroom finds that the defendant has been burdened with probation extended sufficient specified the mother nature of the unique offense, and that even more probation would be fruitless and frustrative for both equally the defendant and probation division,” Napolitano wrote at the time.

But the story and alleged connection amongst Napolitano and Corbishley did not quite close there.

“The criticism declares that Choose Napolitano just lately tried to quit Mr. Corbishley from filing this lawsuit by producing up bogus prison costs towards him,” a press release from Corbishley’s lawful crew alleges. “Specifically, Napolitano not too long ago contacted regulation enforcement officers in New Jersey and told them that Mr. Corbishley experienced built violent threats in opposition to him.  These statements were outright fabrications that Napolitano produced to intimidate Mr. Corbishley and protect against him from filing this lawsuit.”

Napolitano has vehemently and categorically denied all the accusations.

“These accusations are totally untrue,” the previous decide said in a assertion supplied to Law&Criminal offense by his attorney Tom Clare. “Full halt. I have in no way completed everything like what the accuser describes, at any time, to anybody, for any motive. I have under no circumstances had any private connection or inappropriate get hold of or interaction of any sort with the guy making this accusation. Each individual and every a single of his claims from me are pure fiction. Time period.”

Clare referred to as the lawsuit “an outrageous abuse of our court docket system” and mentioned that his client beforehand described Corbishley’s threats to federal legislation enforcement.

“Given Corbishley’s violent past and threats to damage Judge Napolitano, legislation enforcement is monitoring his actions and having extra ways to assure Judge Napolitano’s protection,” the defamation and defense legal professional continued. “We will defeat these wrong allegations in court docket and search ahead to exposing this brazen attemptto smear a focused former general public servant with an abusive courtroom proceeding.”

Napolitano’s longtime employer is also standing by him as of now.

“Judge Napolitano has certain us in the strongest doable phrases that these allegations are untrue and he will fight them aggressively in courtroom,” Fox News stated in a assertion to Legislation&Criminal offense.

Corbishley’s lawyers drew notice to Napolitano’s elite stature.

“For over 30 a long time, our consumer has endured large physical and emotional distress due to the fact of Decide Napolitano’s abhorrent actions,”Joseph & Norinsberg LLC spouse Jon Norinsberg claimed. “We will struggle vigorously on behalf of Mr. Corbishley to guarantee that he gets full justice, and to make positive that Judge Napolitano is ultimately held accountable for his unlawful actions. No man or woman is earlier mentioned the regulation, no make any difference how effective they are or what their station in everyday living is.”

Co-counsel Bennitta L. Joseph extra: “Judge Napolitano perverted the enormous judicial power that we gave him to uphold the law, when he employed his judicial authority to sexually assault Mr. Corbishley. More, Napolitano’s latest use of his judicial electric power and affect to intimidate Mr. Corbishley into silence by fabricating felony fees in opposition to him, reveal almost nothing has changed. Decide Napolitano will not hesitate to use his electrical power and impact to intimidate people today he perceives as powerless when it satisfies his personal agenda.”

The lawsuit seeks $10 million in damages.

Read through the entire criticism under:

Corbishley v. Napolitano by Legislation&Crime on Scribd

Editor’s notice: this tale has been amended publish-publication to consist of statements from the defendant and his attorney.

[image via via Aaron P. Bernstein/Getty Images]

Have a idea we ought to know? [email protected]